Category Archives: fish hatcheries

Sportsmen welcome EPA’s open and transparent process for the Bristol Bay watershed assessment

Continue to demand swift action to protect fishery, jobs, and economy after release of peer review report
Anchorage – Trout Unlimited supports the continued open and transparent process the EPA has conducted in its watershed assessment for Bristol Bay, Alaska. Today, the EPA released its peer review report of the assessment.
“With the release of today’s report, the EPA is showing its continued commitment to a thorough, transparent, independent, and science-based process for protecting Bristol Bay,” said Tim Bristol, TU Alaska Program Director. “The peer review report underscores what we’ve known all along:  mining on the scope and scale of Pebble simply cannot coexist with Bristol Bay’s fish. We call on President Obama to implement necessary protections for this sportsman’s paradise.”
Many of the respected scientists on the peer review panel found that the EPA actually understated the risks of Pebble. One reviewer said that many consequences were “likely” rather than “uncertain” when it comes to Pebble, and another confirmed that EPA evaluated a “realistic” scenario based on Pebble’s extensive filings with the SEC and the Canadian government.  One scientist’s assessment couldn’t be any more clear, “…make no mistake, we cannot have both mining and productive salmon stocks in the Bristol Bay watershed…”
“Bristol Bay is not simply a national treasure; it’s the economic lifeblood for the entire region,” said Brian Kraft, owner of Alaska Sportsman’s and Alaska Sportsman’s Bear Trail Lodges in Bristol Bay.  “The EPA’s assessment and peer review report recognize how Bristol Bay’s sport and commercial fishing economy are wholly dependent on clean water and high quality habitat – the exact things Pebble could destroy. The bottom line is small, renewable resource-based businesses like mine cannot coexist with the Pebble Mine.”
The watershed assessment also concluded that:
  • Bristol Bay’s wild salmon fishery and other natural resources provide at least 14,000 jobs and are valued at about $500 million annually.
  • The average annual run of sockeye salmon is about 37.5 million fish.
  • Even at its minimum size, mining the Pebble deposit would eliminate or block 55 to 87 miles of salmon streams and at least 2500 acres of wetlands – key habitat for sockeye and other fishes.
“As Pebble’s backers have done throughout, they will attack the process and the EPA rather than looking at the facts,” said former Republican Alaska State Senator Rick Halford. “But the fact is, the Pebble Mine is a bad deal for Alaska. Pebble will never be able to account for the many risks associated with the mine, and the peer review report makes these risks abundantly clear. The time to protect Bristol Bay is now.”
The EPA began its watershed assessment in 2011 at the request of Bristol Bay-based Alaska Native tribal governments, commercial fishermen, and sport fishing businesses and organizations.  The 339-page assessment recognizes Bristol Bay as a singular, unmatched global fishery for sockeye salmon and highlights the imminent threats from the proposed Pebble mine.
With the release of the peer review report, Trout Unlimited hopes that EPA will finalize its Bristol Bay Watershed Assessment soon and issue commonsense restrictions to protect Bristol Bay.

Give everyone, not just license buyers, a chance to fund conservation

That’s the theme of my latest newspaper column. You can read it here.

Two-headed trout turn up in Idaho creeks; selenium blamed

And the selenium originates at a phosphate mine that’s operated by the Simplot business. What’s next? How about building another fish hatchery? That’ll do the trick. Don’t worry about the habitat. We have to sell licenses in order to get the revenue so that I get my paycheck on time. Sort of like the on-air fundraisers which public radio stations are infamous for. Her’s a report – from public radio in Boise! – about the two-headed mongrels.

Hatchery mongrels go into Snake River fake lakes

And Idaho F&G emerges as the winner as more license revenue flows into headquarters. But what about conservation and the preservation of habitat? Duh. Details here.

Wild salmon are not holding up, study finds

And the glitch is the release of hatchery-raised fish – mongrels – into the habitat. This feature from the NY Times does the explaining, quite well.

The rainbow trout mistake

Lured by a utopian vision of nature, fish and game agencies dropped billions of trout into thousands of lakes. Now, they’re determined to undo the damage they caused.

This article from Conservation magazine spells it all out. In many cases, rainbows were dumped into water they weren’t native to in a bid to sell more fishing licenses and therefore get more dollars for the state agency’s budget. It’s a story that goes on today with many many hatcheries, including those I’m most familiar with in Pennsylvania. I pleaded again and again over the years for the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission to go out and actually save waters threatened by development, like road building. To no avail.

In defense of fisheries management

Public perception?,0